Why did Mr. Elliot have to decide whose boots were thickest in “Persuasion”?












5















This is from chapter 19 of Jane Austen's Persuasion:




The rain was a mere trifle, and Anne was most sincere in preferring a walk with Mr Elliot. But the rain was also a mere trifle to Mrs Clay; she would hardly allow it even to drop at all, and her boots were so thick! much thicker than Miss Anne’s; and, in short, her civility rendered her quite as anxious to be left to walk with Mr Elliot as Anne could be, and it was discussed between them with a generosity so polite and so determined, that the others were obliged to settle it for them; Miss Elliot maintaining that Mrs Clay had a little cold already, and Mr Elliot deciding on appeal, that his cousin Anne’s boots were rather the thickest.





  1. What is the meaning of the phrase "as Anne could be"?


  2. Is it that even though Mrs. Clay's boots were the thickest, Mr. Elliot was compelled to decide that Anne should be the one who should walk because her boots were the thickest as decided by the others?











share|improve this question





























    5















    This is from chapter 19 of Jane Austen's Persuasion:




    The rain was a mere trifle, and Anne was most sincere in preferring a walk with Mr Elliot. But the rain was also a mere trifle to Mrs Clay; she would hardly allow it even to drop at all, and her boots were so thick! much thicker than Miss Anne’s; and, in short, her civility rendered her quite as anxious to be left to walk with Mr Elliot as Anne could be, and it was discussed between them with a generosity so polite and so determined, that the others were obliged to settle it for them; Miss Elliot maintaining that Mrs Clay had a little cold already, and Mr Elliot deciding on appeal, that his cousin Anne’s boots were rather the thickest.





    1. What is the meaning of the phrase "as Anne could be"?


    2. Is it that even though Mrs. Clay's boots were the thickest, Mr. Elliot was compelled to decide that Anne should be the one who should walk because her boots were the thickest as decided by the others?











    share|improve this question



























      5












      5








      5


      1






      This is from chapter 19 of Jane Austen's Persuasion:




      The rain was a mere trifle, and Anne was most sincere in preferring a walk with Mr Elliot. But the rain was also a mere trifle to Mrs Clay; she would hardly allow it even to drop at all, and her boots were so thick! much thicker than Miss Anne’s; and, in short, her civility rendered her quite as anxious to be left to walk with Mr Elliot as Anne could be, and it was discussed between them with a generosity so polite and so determined, that the others were obliged to settle it for them; Miss Elliot maintaining that Mrs Clay had a little cold already, and Mr Elliot deciding on appeal, that his cousin Anne’s boots were rather the thickest.





      1. What is the meaning of the phrase "as Anne could be"?


      2. Is it that even though Mrs. Clay's boots were the thickest, Mr. Elliot was compelled to decide that Anne should be the one who should walk because her boots were the thickest as decided by the others?











      share|improve this question
















      This is from chapter 19 of Jane Austen's Persuasion:




      The rain was a mere trifle, and Anne was most sincere in preferring a walk with Mr Elliot. But the rain was also a mere trifle to Mrs Clay; she would hardly allow it even to drop at all, and her boots were so thick! much thicker than Miss Anne’s; and, in short, her civility rendered her quite as anxious to be left to walk with Mr Elliot as Anne could be, and it was discussed between them with a generosity so polite and so determined, that the others were obliged to settle it for them; Miss Elliot maintaining that Mrs Clay had a little cold already, and Mr Elliot deciding on appeal, that his cousin Anne’s boots were rather the thickest.





      1. What is the meaning of the phrase "as Anne could be"?


      2. Is it that even though Mrs. Clay's boots were the thickest, Mr. Elliot was compelled to decide that Anne should be the one who should walk because her boots were the thickest as decided by the others?








      meaning jane-austen persuasion






      share|improve this question















      share|improve this question













      share|improve this question




      share|improve this question








      edited Feb 25 at 10:42









      Gareth Rees

      6,97811468




      6,97811468










      asked Feb 25 at 10:04









      SoumeeSoumee

      1877




      1877






















          1 Answer
          1






          active

          oldest

          votes


















          11















          1. The phrase needs to be understood as “as X as Anne could be” where X is “anxious to be left to walk with Mr. Elliot”. That is, Mrs. Clay wanted, just as much as Anne did, to walk alone with Mr. Elliot.



          2. The context is that Mr. Elliot, Miss Elliot, Anne, and Mrs. Clay are out walking in Bath when it starts raining. Mrs. Dalrymple offers to take them home in her carriage. However, the carriage is a barouche and only has covered seating for four. Mrs. Dalrymple and Miss Carteret are two, and Miss Elliot immediately claims the third place (“Whoever suffered inconvenience, she must suffer none”). This leaves one place for either Mrs. Clay or Anne; the other must therefore walk back in the rain with Mr. Elliot.



            It becomes apparent that Mrs. Clay and Anne both want to be left alone with Mr. Elliot. Mrs. Clay’s reason for this is still a mystery as of chapter 19, but Anne’s, we understand, is that she is still puzzled as to Mr. Elliot’s motives in renewing acquiantance with his family. Does he intend to propose marriage to Miss Elliot? She hopes that if she can converse with him privately he may reveal something. (In the event she squanders this opportunity, all other concerns being driven out by the appearance of Captain Wentworth.)



            Neither of them wishes to admit her motive for seeking a private conversation with Mr. Elliot, so instead each pretends that she is concerned that the other will get wet feet. (This is the “generosity so polite and so determined”.) Since neither is willing to give up in favour of the other, eventually “the others were obliged to settle it for them” and Mr. Elliot settles the matter in favour of Anne. It seems likely that his judgement about the relative thickness of the boots is just a pretext, and really he prefers the company of Anne.



          3. The phrase “deciding on appeal” humorously likens the situation to a court case. In English law, a party that is dissatisfied with a decision in a lower court can appeal to a higher court for a review of the decision. In this metaphor, Mr. Elliot represents the appellate court, with his decision the final one.







          share|improve this answer


























          • "Mr. Eliot decided on appeal": Does this mean that Mr. Eliot insisted(based on his own opinions) that Anne's boots were the thickest or this was an opinion he generated based on what the others said?

            – Soumee
            Feb 25 at 13:24













          • "Mr. Eliot decided on appeal": Does this mean that Mr. Eliot insisted that Anne's boots were the thickest or this was an opinion he generated based on what the others said?

            – Soumee
            Feb 25 at 13:24






          • 3





            @Soumee I think you are missing the point. The shoe thickness issue was only a pretext, and understood as such by all the characters. The issue was which of the ladies should have a private conversation with Mr. Elliot, and he got to pick.

            – Patricia Shanahan
            Feb 25 at 17:04






          • 1





            @PatriciaShanahan Precisely. Gareth's answer appeared while I was drafting mine (essentially the same points made so no need for mine to be posted) but mine was going to open with 'The substantive issue is not whose boots were the thickest, it is who Mr Elliot gets to go walking with!'

            – Spagirl
            Feb 26 at 10:52











          Your Answer








          StackExchange.ready(function() {
          var channelOptions = {
          tags: "".split(" "),
          id: "668"
          };
          initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

          StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
          // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
          if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
          StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
          createEditor();
          });
          }
          else {
          createEditor();
          }
          });

          function createEditor() {
          StackExchange.prepareEditor({
          heartbeatType: 'answer',
          autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
          convertImagesToLinks: false,
          noModals: true,
          showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
          reputationToPostImages: null,
          bindNavPrevention: true,
          postfix: "",
          imageUploader: {
          brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
          contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
          allowUrls: true
          },
          noCode: true, onDemand: true,
          discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
          ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
          });


          }
          });














          draft saved

          draft discarded


















          StackExchange.ready(
          function () {
          StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fliterature.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f9462%2fwhy-did-mr-elliot-have-to-decide-whose-boots-were-thickest-in-persuasion%23new-answer', 'question_page');
          }
          );

          Post as a guest















          Required, but never shown

























          1 Answer
          1






          active

          oldest

          votes








          1 Answer
          1






          active

          oldest

          votes









          active

          oldest

          votes






          active

          oldest

          votes









          11















          1. The phrase needs to be understood as “as X as Anne could be” where X is “anxious to be left to walk with Mr. Elliot”. That is, Mrs. Clay wanted, just as much as Anne did, to walk alone with Mr. Elliot.



          2. The context is that Mr. Elliot, Miss Elliot, Anne, and Mrs. Clay are out walking in Bath when it starts raining. Mrs. Dalrymple offers to take them home in her carriage. However, the carriage is a barouche and only has covered seating for four. Mrs. Dalrymple and Miss Carteret are two, and Miss Elliot immediately claims the third place (“Whoever suffered inconvenience, she must suffer none”). This leaves one place for either Mrs. Clay or Anne; the other must therefore walk back in the rain with Mr. Elliot.



            It becomes apparent that Mrs. Clay and Anne both want to be left alone with Mr. Elliot. Mrs. Clay’s reason for this is still a mystery as of chapter 19, but Anne’s, we understand, is that she is still puzzled as to Mr. Elliot’s motives in renewing acquiantance with his family. Does he intend to propose marriage to Miss Elliot? She hopes that if she can converse with him privately he may reveal something. (In the event she squanders this opportunity, all other concerns being driven out by the appearance of Captain Wentworth.)



            Neither of them wishes to admit her motive for seeking a private conversation with Mr. Elliot, so instead each pretends that she is concerned that the other will get wet feet. (This is the “generosity so polite and so determined”.) Since neither is willing to give up in favour of the other, eventually “the others were obliged to settle it for them” and Mr. Elliot settles the matter in favour of Anne. It seems likely that his judgement about the relative thickness of the boots is just a pretext, and really he prefers the company of Anne.



          3. The phrase “deciding on appeal” humorously likens the situation to a court case. In English law, a party that is dissatisfied with a decision in a lower court can appeal to a higher court for a review of the decision. In this metaphor, Mr. Elliot represents the appellate court, with his decision the final one.







          share|improve this answer


























          • "Mr. Eliot decided on appeal": Does this mean that Mr. Eliot insisted(based on his own opinions) that Anne's boots were the thickest or this was an opinion he generated based on what the others said?

            – Soumee
            Feb 25 at 13:24













          • "Mr. Eliot decided on appeal": Does this mean that Mr. Eliot insisted that Anne's boots were the thickest or this was an opinion he generated based on what the others said?

            – Soumee
            Feb 25 at 13:24






          • 3





            @Soumee I think you are missing the point. The shoe thickness issue was only a pretext, and understood as such by all the characters. The issue was which of the ladies should have a private conversation with Mr. Elliot, and he got to pick.

            – Patricia Shanahan
            Feb 25 at 17:04






          • 1





            @PatriciaShanahan Precisely. Gareth's answer appeared while I was drafting mine (essentially the same points made so no need for mine to be posted) but mine was going to open with 'The substantive issue is not whose boots were the thickest, it is who Mr Elliot gets to go walking with!'

            – Spagirl
            Feb 26 at 10:52
















          11















          1. The phrase needs to be understood as “as X as Anne could be” where X is “anxious to be left to walk with Mr. Elliot”. That is, Mrs. Clay wanted, just as much as Anne did, to walk alone with Mr. Elliot.



          2. The context is that Mr. Elliot, Miss Elliot, Anne, and Mrs. Clay are out walking in Bath when it starts raining. Mrs. Dalrymple offers to take them home in her carriage. However, the carriage is a barouche and only has covered seating for four. Mrs. Dalrymple and Miss Carteret are two, and Miss Elliot immediately claims the third place (“Whoever suffered inconvenience, she must suffer none”). This leaves one place for either Mrs. Clay or Anne; the other must therefore walk back in the rain with Mr. Elliot.



            It becomes apparent that Mrs. Clay and Anne both want to be left alone with Mr. Elliot. Mrs. Clay’s reason for this is still a mystery as of chapter 19, but Anne’s, we understand, is that she is still puzzled as to Mr. Elliot’s motives in renewing acquiantance with his family. Does he intend to propose marriage to Miss Elliot? She hopes that if she can converse with him privately he may reveal something. (In the event she squanders this opportunity, all other concerns being driven out by the appearance of Captain Wentworth.)



            Neither of them wishes to admit her motive for seeking a private conversation with Mr. Elliot, so instead each pretends that she is concerned that the other will get wet feet. (This is the “generosity so polite and so determined”.) Since neither is willing to give up in favour of the other, eventually “the others were obliged to settle it for them” and Mr. Elliot settles the matter in favour of Anne. It seems likely that his judgement about the relative thickness of the boots is just a pretext, and really he prefers the company of Anne.



          3. The phrase “deciding on appeal” humorously likens the situation to a court case. In English law, a party that is dissatisfied with a decision in a lower court can appeal to a higher court for a review of the decision. In this metaphor, Mr. Elliot represents the appellate court, with his decision the final one.







          share|improve this answer


























          • "Mr. Eliot decided on appeal": Does this mean that Mr. Eliot insisted(based on his own opinions) that Anne's boots were the thickest or this was an opinion he generated based on what the others said?

            – Soumee
            Feb 25 at 13:24













          • "Mr. Eliot decided on appeal": Does this mean that Mr. Eliot insisted that Anne's boots were the thickest or this was an opinion he generated based on what the others said?

            – Soumee
            Feb 25 at 13:24






          • 3





            @Soumee I think you are missing the point. The shoe thickness issue was only a pretext, and understood as such by all the characters. The issue was which of the ladies should have a private conversation with Mr. Elliot, and he got to pick.

            – Patricia Shanahan
            Feb 25 at 17:04






          • 1





            @PatriciaShanahan Precisely. Gareth's answer appeared while I was drafting mine (essentially the same points made so no need for mine to be posted) but mine was going to open with 'The substantive issue is not whose boots were the thickest, it is who Mr Elliot gets to go walking with!'

            – Spagirl
            Feb 26 at 10:52














          11












          11








          11








          1. The phrase needs to be understood as “as X as Anne could be” where X is “anxious to be left to walk with Mr. Elliot”. That is, Mrs. Clay wanted, just as much as Anne did, to walk alone with Mr. Elliot.



          2. The context is that Mr. Elliot, Miss Elliot, Anne, and Mrs. Clay are out walking in Bath when it starts raining. Mrs. Dalrymple offers to take them home in her carriage. However, the carriage is a barouche and only has covered seating for four. Mrs. Dalrymple and Miss Carteret are two, and Miss Elliot immediately claims the third place (“Whoever suffered inconvenience, she must suffer none”). This leaves one place for either Mrs. Clay or Anne; the other must therefore walk back in the rain with Mr. Elliot.



            It becomes apparent that Mrs. Clay and Anne both want to be left alone with Mr. Elliot. Mrs. Clay’s reason for this is still a mystery as of chapter 19, but Anne’s, we understand, is that she is still puzzled as to Mr. Elliot’s motives in renewing acquiantance with his family. Does he intend to propose marriage to Miss Elliot? She hopes that if she can converse with him privately he may reveal something. (In the event she squanders this opportunity, all other concerns being driven out by the appearance of Captain Wentworth.)



            Neither of them wishes to admit her motive for seeking a private conversation with Mr. Elliot, so instead each pretends that she is concerned that the other will get wet feet. (This is the “generosity so polite and so determined”.) Since neither is willing to give up in favour of the other, eventually “the others were obliged to settle it for them” and Mr. Elliot settles the matter in favour of Anne. It seems likely that his judgement about the relative thickness of the boots is just a pretext, and really he prefers the company of Anne.



          3. The phrase “deciding on appeal” humorously likens the situation to a court case. In English law, a party that is dissatisfied with a decision in a lower court can appeal to a higher court for a review of the decision. In this metaphor, Mr. Elliot represents the appellate court, with his decision the final one.







          share|improve this answer
















          1. The phrase needs to be understood as “as X as Anne could be” where X is “anxious to be left to walk with Mr. Elliot”. That is, Mrs. Clay wanted, just as much as Anne did, to walk alone with Mr. Elliot.



          2. The context is that Mr. Elliot, Miss Elliot, Anne, and Mrs. Clay are out walking in Bath when it starts raining. Mrs. Dalrymple offers to take them home in her carriage. However, the carriage is a barouche and only has covered seating for four. Mrs. Dalrymple and Miss Carteret are two, and Miss Elliot immediately claims the third place (“Whoever suffered inconvenience, she must suffer none”). This leaves one place for either Mrs. Clay or Anne; the other must therefore walk back in the rain with Mr. Elliot.



            It becomes apparent that Mrs. Clay and Anne both want to be left alone with Mr. Elliot. Mrs. Clay’s reason for this is still a mystery as of chapter 19, but Anne’s, we understand, is that she is still puzzled as to Mr. Elliot’s motives in renewing acquiantance with his family. Does he intend to propose marriage to Miss Elliot? She hopes that if she can converse with him privately he may reveal something. (In the event she squanders this opportunity, all other concerns being driven out by the appearance of Captain Wentworth.)



            Neither of them wishes to admit her motive for seeking a private conversation with Mr. Elliot, so instead each pretends that she is concerned that the other will get wet feet. (This is the “generosity so polite and so determined”.) Since neither is willing to give up in favour of the other, eventually “the others were obliged to settle it for them” and Mr. Elliot settles the matter in favour of Anne. It seems likely that his judgement about the relative thickness of the boots is just a pretext, and really he prefers the company of Anne.



          3. The phrase “deciding on appeal” humorously likens the situation to a court case. In English law, a party that is dissatisfied with a decision in a lower court can appeal to a higher court for a review of the decision. In this metaphor, Mr. Elliot represents the appellate court, with his decision the final one.








          share|improve this answer














          share|improve this answer



          share|improve this answer








          edited Feb 25 at 13:42

























          answered Feb 25 at 11:14









          Gareth ReesGareth Rees

          6,97811468




          6,97811468













          • "Mr. Eliot decided on appeal": Does this mean that Mr. Eliot insisted(based on his own opinions) that Anne's boots were the thickest or this was an opinion he generated based on what the others said?

            – Soumee
            Feb 25 at 13:24













          • "Mr. Eliot decided on appeal": Does this mean that Mr. Eliot insisted that Anne's boots were the thickest or this was an opinion he generated based on what the others said?

            – Soumee
            Feb 25 at 13:24






          • 3





            @Soumee I think you are missing the point. The shoe thickness issue was only a pretext, and understood as such by all the characters. The issue was which of the ladies should have a private conversation with Mr. Elliot, and he got to pick.

            – Patricia Shanahan
            Feb 25 at 17:04






          • 1





            @PatriciaShanahan Precisely. Gareth's answer appeared while I was drafting mine (essentially the same points made so no need for mine to be posted) but mine was going to open with 'The substantive issue is not whose boots were the thickest, it is who Mr Elliot gets to go walking with!'

            – Spagirl
            Feb 26 at 10:52



















          • "Mr. Eliot decided on appeal": Does this mean that Mr. Eliot insisted(based on his own opinions) that Anne's boots were the thickest or this was an opinion he generated based on what the others said?

            – Soumee
            Feb 25 at 13:24













          • "Mr. Eliot decided on appeal": Does this mean that Mr. Eliot insisted that Anne's boots were the thickest or this was an opinion he generated based on what the others said?

            – Soumee
            Feb 25 at 13:24






          • 3





            @Soumee I think you are missing the point. The shoe thickness issue was only a pretext, and understood as such by all the characters. The issue was which of the ladies should have a private conversation with Mr. Elliot, and he got to pick.

            – Patricia Shanahan
            Feb 25 at 17:04






          • 1





            @PatriciaShanahan Precisely. Gareth's answer appeared while I was drafting mine (essentially the same points made so no need for mine to be posted) but mine was going to open with 'The substantive issue is not whose boots were the thickest, it is who Mr Elliot gets to go walking with!'

            – Spagirl
            Feb 26 at 10:52

















          "Mr. Eliot decided on appeal": Does this mean that Mr. Eliot insisted(based on his own opinions) that Anne's boots were the thickest or this was an opinion he generated based on what the others said?

          – Soumee
          Feb 25 at 13:24







          "Mr. Eliot decided on appeal": Does this mean that Mr. Eliot insisted(based on his own opinions) that Anne's boots were the thickest or this was an opinion he generated based on what the others said?

          – Soumee
          Feb 25 at 13:24















          "Mr. Eliot decided on appeal": Does this mean that Mr. Eliot insisted that Anne's boots were the thickest or this was an opinion he generated based on what the others said?

          – Soumee
          Feb 25 at 13:24





          "Mr. Eliot decided on appeal": Does this mean that Mr. Eliot insisted that Anne's boots were the thickest or this was an opinion he generated based on what the others said?

          – Soumee
          Feb 25 at 13:24




          3




          3





          @Soumee I think you are missing the point. The shoe thickness issue was only a pretext, and understood as such by all the characters. The issue was which of the ladies should have a private conversation with Mr. Elliot, and he got to pick.

          – Patricia Shanahan
          Feb 25 at 17:04





          @Soumee I think you are missing the point. The shoe thickness issue was only a pretext, and understood as such by all the characters. The issue was which of the ladies should have a private conversation with Mr. Elliot, and he got to pick.

          – Patricia Shanahan
          Feb 25 at 17:04




          1




          1





          @PatriciaShanahan Precisely. Gareth's answer appeared while I was drafting mine (essentially the same points made so no need for mine to be posted) but mine was going to open with 'The substantive issue is not whose boots were the thickest, it is who Mr Elliot gets to go walking with!'

          – Spagirl
          Feb 26 at 10:52





          @PatriciaShanahan Precisely. Gareth's answer appeared while I was drafting mine (essentially the same points made so no need for mine to be posted) but mine was going to open with 'The substantive issue is not whose boots were the thickest, it is who Mr Elliot gets to go walking with!'

          – Spagirl
          Feb 26 at 10:52


















          draft saved

          draft discarded




















































          Thanks for contributing an answer to Literature Stack Exchange!


          • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

          But avoid



          • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

          • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


          To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




          draft saved


          draft discarded














          StackExchange.ready(
          function () {
          StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fliterature.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f9462%2fwhy-did-mr-elliot-have-to-decide-whose-boots-were-thickest-in-persuasion%23new-answer', 'question_page');
          }
          );

          Post as a guest















          Required, but never shown





















































          Required, but never shown














          Required, but never shown












          Required, but never shown







          Required, but never shown

































          Required, but never shown














          Required, but never shown












          Required, but never shown







          Required, but never shown







          Popular posts from this blog

          How to change which sound is reproduced for terminal bell?

          Can I use Tabulator js library in my java Spring + Thymeleaf project?

          Title Spacing in Bjornstrup Chapter, Removing Chapter Number From Contents