Cfrgtkky

I'm having trouble understanding how the exit() selection works in my grouped bar chart. My example has only empty exit() selections, and thus nothing is removed from the chart when it's updated.

This is similar to the problem posted here: d3 grouped bar chart update pattern not working. But since I append an 'g' to the chartArea object I don't think the solution is applicable.

I am loosely following the grouped/stacked bar chart example from here: https://bl.ocks.org/aholachek/fb0c1cd7ea9707bc8ff55a82402c54b1

The full jsfiddle https://jsfiddle.net/fg_ti/ka306sjc/68/ and the code:

var data1 = [

  {

    "sex": "female",

    "n_patients": 5,

    "grouping":"A"

  },

  {

    "sex": "male",

    "n_patients": 10,

    "grouping": "A"

  },

  {

    "sex": "female",

    "n_patients": 25,

    "grouping":"B"

  },

  {

    "sex": "male",

    "n_patients": 10,

    "grouping":"B"

  }];

var data2 = [

  {

    "sex": "female",

    "n_patients": 62,

    "grouping":"A"

  },

  {

    "sex": "male",

    "n_patients": 55,

    "grouping":"A"

  },

  {

    "sex": "female",

    "n_patients": 25,

    "grouping": "B"

  },

  {

    "sex": "male",

    "n_patients": 83,

    "grouping":"B"

  },

  {

   "sex": "female",

   "n_patients": 25,

   "grouping": "D"},

  {

    "sex": "male",

    "n_patients": 83,

    "grouping": "D"

   }];



width = 350;

height = 450;



var initData = d3.nest().key(d => d.grouping).entries(data1)

var margin = ({top:10, right:10, bottom:10, left:30});

var Gwidth = width - margin.left - margin.right

var Gheight = height - margin.top - margin.bottom

var barPadding = 0.1;



var colors = ['#ffe1e1', '#d1ecfd']

svg = d3.select('body').append('svg')

    .attr("width", width + margin.left + margin.right)

    .attr("height", height + margin.top + margin.bottom)

var topG = svg.append('g')

    .attr('transform', 'translate(' + margin.left + ',' + margin.top +')')





// Initial scale



// Scale between the keys (i.e. b/w age groups, edu, etc`)

var scaleX = d3.scaleBand()

  .domain(initData.map(d => d.key))

  .range([0, Gwidth])

  .padding(barPadding);



var scaleColors = d3.scaleOrdinal()

    .range(colors)



// Initial axis

var yAxis = topG.append('g')

  .attr("class", "y axis")



var xAxis = topG.append('g')

    .attr("class", "x axis")



xAxis.call(d3.axisBottom(scaleX))

    .attr("transform", 'translate(' + 0 + "," + Gheight + ')');



var chartArea = topG.append("g")

    .attr("class", "chartArea");







// UPDATE FUNCTION - will be called by r2d3.onRender()

function update(inData) {



  // Reshape data

  var newData = d3.nest()

    .key(d => d.grouping)

    .entries(inData);





  var maxY = d3.max(newData, d => d3.max(d.values, k => k.n_patients));

  grouping1Names = newData.map(d => d.key);

  grouping2Names = newData[0].values.map(d => d.sex);

  var t = 1000;



  // Scales used in updates 

  var scaleY = d3.scaleLinear()

    .domain([0, maxY])

    .range([Gheight, 0]);



  var scaleX = d3.scaleBand()

    .domain(grouping1Names)

    .range([0, Gwidth])

    .padding(barPadding);



  var scaleX1 = d3.scaleBand()

    .domain(grouping2Names)

    .rangeRound([0, scaleX.bandwidth()]);





  // Perform the data join



   var barGroupWithData = chartArea

      .selectAll('.barGroup')

      .data(newData);



    barGroupWithData.exit().remove();



   // Join rect elements with data - specified with keys

   var bars = barGroupWithData.enter()

      .append("g")

      .attr("transform", d => "translate(" + scaleX(d.key) + ",0)")

      .attr("fill", "steelblue")

      .merge(barGroupWithData)

      .selectAll("rect")

          .data(d => Object.keys(d.values)

                          .map(k => ({ keyL2: grouping2Names[k], value: d.values[k].n_patients }) ));







  console.log(bars)



  // Remove rect elements joined with data that is no longer present

  bars.exit().remove()



  bars.enter()

    .append("rect")

    .attr("fill", d => scaleColors(d.keyL2))

    .attr("y", d => scaleY(0))

    .merge(bars)

    .attr("x", (d) => scaleX1(d.keyL2))

    .attr("width", scaleX1.bandwidth())

    .transition()

    .duration(t)

    .ease(d3.easeLinear)

    .attr('y', d => scaleY(d.value))

    .attr("height", d => scaleY(0) - scaleY(d.value));



  console.log(bars)



  // Udpate axes

  yAxis.transition()

    .duration(t)

    .call(d3.axisLeft(scaleY))



  xAxis.transition()

    .duration(t)

    .call(d3.axisBottom(scaleX))



}



//





update(data1);



 // Update the data

  setInterval(function (newDat) {



            if(Math.random()>0.5) {

            d = data1

            } else {

            d = data2

            }





            return update(d);

        }, 3000);

I suspect I am not joining the data correctly, but cannot pinpoint where this goes wrong. The first posted answer to this questions seems close, but does not work for my solution: Exit() is not working for d3 group bar chart.

Any advice to properly removing the old data from the chart?

==================== EDIT =============

To clarify, I modified the data to highlight the problem better (updated jsfidlde). The data seems to join to the rect elements fine - with each update, new bars are appended. However the old rect elements are not removed.
Since the keys for joining data to the rects are specified as such:

(.data(d => Object.keys(d.values)

                              .map(k => ({ keyL2: grouping2Names[k], value: d.values[k].n_patients }) ));` `.enter()`

I therefore expected the .data() to match the incoming data against the data in the existing rect elements. If incoming data has different values for n_patients or grouping, I would think d3 would recognize the new data as "entering" and append, and conversely, already existing data whose n_patient or grouping values are not matched with the new data as "exiting" and remove. This is based on the responses to this question: D3 Key Function; and an old blog post from Mike Bostock

Since new rects are appended in each .enter() call, it seems d3 is recognizing the "entering" data, but not recognizing the "exiting" data in the way I have written my code. Can anyone shed light on this?