Can a Jewish man be a sperm donor?
up vote
3
down vote
favorite
What are the Halachik issues with donating sperm in a non-Jewish community?
halacha pregnancy-birth
edited Nov 28 at 7:38
Al Berko
4,102426
asked Nov 28 at 1:05
Lages
843
add a comment |
up vote
3
down vote
favorite
What are the Halachik issues with donating sperm in a non-Jewish community?
halacha pregnancy-birth
edited Nov 28 at 7:38
Al Berko
4,102426
asked Nov 28 at 1:05
Lages
843
add a comment |
up vote
3
down vote
favorite
up vote
3
down vote
favorite
What are the Halachik issues with donating sperm in a non-Jewish community?
halacha pregnancy-birth
edited Nov 28 at 7:38
Al Berko
4,102426
asked Nov 28 at 1:05
Lages
843
What are the Halachik issues with donating sperm in a non-Jewish community?
halacha pregnancy-birth
halacha pregnancy-birth
edited Nov 28 at 7:38
Al Berko
4,102426
asked Nov 28 at 1:05
Lages
843
edited Nov 28 at 7:38
Al Berko
4,102426
asked Nov 28 at 1:05
Lages
843
edited Nov 28 at 7:38
Al Berko
4,102426
edited Nov 28 at 7:38
Al Berko
4,102426
edited Nov 28 at 7:38
Al Berko
4,102426
4,102426
asked Nov 28 at 1:05
Lages
843
asked Nov 28 at 1:05
Lages
843
asked Nov 28 at 1:05
Lages
843
843
add a comment |
add a comment |
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
up vote
7
down vote
No, a Jewish man cannot be a sperm donor.
Based on tshuvos from Reb Moshe (Igrot Moshe, Even Ha'Ezer 1:71 & 4:32.5) we can say
Niuff byad is an issur which only married couples who undergo IVF can get around, but single guys in a clinic can't.
The assumption is that the sperm will go to a nonjew, so there is no kiyum of pru urvu to dissipate the issur of hotzaas zera livatala.
Since you can't guarantee that a Jewish woman won't end up impregnated with said sperm, you run into a problem of siblings from the same father possibly marrying each other, which is arayos and makes mamzeirim.
answered Nov 28 at 1:26
user6591
24.9k12656
Do we need Kiyum Pru uRvu to dissipate it? Wouldn't we still allow for Bedika of a Kerut Shofkha to allow him to marry an Aylonit?
– Double AA♦
Nov 28 at 1:53
I'm not familiar with that. I thought we don't ever allow bedikos for marriage. If you have something to share I'd be iinterested in seeing it.
– user6591
Nov 28 at 2:11
I thought RMFs whole proof was from a Gemara in Yevamot about checking a Krut Shofkha to see if he could marry, and IVF is a Kol Shekein
– Double AA♦
Nov 28 at 2:16
@Double He mentions the theoretical case of using hot bread to test without niuf yes, but I don't think he believes that is actually muttar to do. The gemara itself was docheh that approach. Have you ever seen someone allowing that bedika?
– user6591
Nov 28 at 2:49
2
This answer would be vastly improved if it would at the very least list the responsa of R'MF it refers to. Ideally, it should say how it got from them to its conclusions. Oh, and translating words into English would help, too.
– msh210♦
Nov 28 at 4:25
|
show 2 more comments
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
7
down vote
No, a Jewish man cannot be a sperm donor.
Based on tshuvos from Reb Moshe (Igrot Moshe, Even Ha'Ezer 1:71 & 4:32.5) we can say
Niuff byad is an issur which only married couples who undergo IVF can get around, but single guys in a clinic can't.
The assumption is that the sperm will go to a nonjew, so there is no kiyum of pru urvu to dissipate the issur of hotzaas zera livatala.
Since you can't guarantee that a Jewish woman won't end up impregnated with said sperm, you run into a problem of siblings from the same father possibly marrying each other, which is arayos and makes mamzeirim.
answered Nov 28 at 1:26
user6591
24.9k12656
Do we need Kiyum Pru uRvu to dissipate it? Wouldn't we still allow for Bedika of a Kerut Shofkha to allow him to marry an Aylonit?
– Double AA♦
Nov 28 at 1:53
I'm not familiar with that. I thought we don't ever allow bedikos for marriage. If you have something to share I'd be iinterested in seeing it.
– user6591
Nov 28 at 2:11
I thought RMFs whole proof was from a Gemara in Yevamot about checking a Krut Shofkha to see if he could marry, and IVF is a Kol Shekein
– Double AA♦
Nov 28 at 2:16
@Double He mentions the theoretical case of using hot bread to test without niuf yes, but I don't think he believes that is actually muttar to do. The gemara itself was docheh that approach. Have you ever seen someone allowing that bedika?
– user6591
Nov 28 at 2:49
2
This answer would be vastly improved if it would at the very least list the responsa of R'MF it refers to. Ideally, it should say how it got from them to its conclusions. Oh, and translating words into English would help, too.
– msh210♦
Nov 28 at 4:25
|
show 2 more comments
up vote
7
down vote
No, a Jewish man cannot be a sperm donor.
Based on tshuvos from Reb Moshe (Igrot Moshe, Even Ha'Ezer 1:71 & 4:32.5) we can say
Niuff byad is an issur which only married couples who undergo IVF can get around, but single guys in a clinic can't.
The assumption is that the sperm will go to a nonjew, so there is no kiyum of pru urvu to dissipate the issur of hotzaas zera livatala.
Since you can't guarantee that a Jewish woman won't end up impregnated with said sperm, you run into a problem of siblings from the same father possibly marrying each other, which is arayos and makes mamzeirim.
answered Nov 28 at 1:26
user6591
24.9k12656
Do we need Kiyum Pru uRvu to dissipate it? Wouldn't we still allow for Bedika of a Kerut Shofkha to allow him to marry an Aylonit?
– Double AA♦
Nov 28 at 1:53
I'm not familiar with that. I thought we don't ever allow bedikos for marriage. If you have something to share I'd be iinterested in seeing it.
– user6591
Nov 28 at 2:11
I thought RMFs whole proof was from a Gemara in Yevamot about checking a Krut Shofkha to see if he could marry, and IVF is a Kol Shekein
– Double AA♦
Nov 28 at 2:16
@Double He mentions the theoretical case of using hot bread to test without niuf yes, but I don't think he believes that is actually muttar to do. The gemara itself was docheh that approach. Have you ever seen someone allowing that bedika?
– user6591
Nov 28 at 2:49
2
This answer would be vastly improved if it would at the very least list the responsa of R'MF it refers to. Ideally, it should say how it got from them to its conclusions. Oh, and translating words into English would help, too.
– msh210♦
Nov 28 at 4:25
|
show 2 more comments
up vote
7
down vote
up vote
7
down vote
No, a Jewish man cannot be a sperm donor.
Based on tshuvos from Reb Moshe (Igrot Moshe, Even Ha'Ezer 1:71 & 4:32.5) we can say
Niuff byad is an issur which only married couples who undergo IVF can get around, but single guys in a clinic can't.
The assumption is that the sperm will go to a nonjew, so there is no kiyum of pru urvu to dissipate the issur of hotzaas zera livatala.
Since you can't guarantee that a Jewish woman won't end up impregnated with said sperm, you run into a problem of siblings from the same father possibly marrying each other, which is arayos and makes mamzeirim.
answered Nov 28 at 1:26
user6591
24.9k12656
No, a Jewish man cannot be a sperm donor.
Based on tshuvos from Reb Moshe (Igrot Moshe, Even Ha'Ezer 1:71 & 4:32.5) we can say
Niuff byad is an issur which only married couples who undergo IVF can get around, but single guys in a clinic can't.
The assumption is that the sperm will go to a nonjew, so there is no kiyum of pru urvu to dissipate the issur of hotzaas zera livatala.
Since you can't guarantee that a Jewish woman won't end up impregnated with said sperm, you run into a problem of siblings from the same father possibly marrying each other, which is arayos and makes mamzeirim.
answered Nov 28 at 1:26
user6591
24.9k12656
edited Nov 28 at 13:51
answered Nov 28 at 1:26
user6591
24.9k12656
answered Nov 28 at 1:26
user6591
24.9k12656
answered Nov 28 at 1:26
user6591
24.9k12656
24.9k12656
Do we need Kiyum Pru uRvu to dissipate it? Wouldn't we still allow for Bedika of a Kerut Shofkha to allow him to marry an Aylonit?
– Double AA♦
Nov 28 at 1:53
I'm not familiar with that. I thought we don't ever allow bedikos for marriage. If you have something to share I'd be iinterested in seeing it.
– user6591
Nov 28 at 2:11
I thought RMFs whole proof was from a Gemara in Yevamot about checking a Krut Shofkha to see if he could marry, and IVF is a Kol Shekein
– Double AA♦
Nov 28 at 2:16
@Double He mentions the theoretical case of using hot bread to test without niuf yes, but I don't think he believes that is actually muttar to do. The gemara itself was docheh that approach. Have you ever seen someone allowing that bedika?
– user6591
Nov 28 at 2:49
2
This answer would be vastly improved if it would at the very least list the responsa of R'MF it refers to. Ideally, it should say how it got from them to its conclusions. Oh, and translating words into English would help, too.
– msh210♦
Nov 28 at 4:25
|
show 2 more comments
Do we need Kiyum Pru uRvu to dissipate it? Wouldn't we still allow for Bedika of a Kerut Shofkha to allow him to marry an Aylonit?
– Double AA♦
Nov 28 at 1:53
I'm not familiar with that. I thought we don't ever allow bedikos for marriage. If you have something to share I'd be iinterested in seeing it.
– user6591
Nov 28 at 2:11
I thought RMFs whole proof was from a Gemara in Yevamot about checking a Krut Shofkha to see if he could marry, and IVF is a Kol Shekein
– Double AA♦
Nov 28 at 2:16
@Double He mentions the theoretical case of using hot bread to test without niuf yes, but I don't think he believes that is actually muttar to do. The gemara itself was docheh that approach. Have you ever seen someone allowing that bedika?
– user6591
Nov 28 at 2:49
2
This answer would be vastly improved if it would at the very least list the responsa of R'MF it refers to. Ideally, it should say how it got from them to its conclusions. Oh, and translating words into English would help, too.
– msh210♦
Nov 28 at 4:25
Do we need Kiyum Pru uRvu to dissipate it? Wouldn't we still allow for Bedika of a Kerut Shofkha to allow him to marry an Aylonit?
– Double AA♦
Nov 28 at 1:53
Do we need Kiyum Pru uRvu to dissipate it? Wouldn't we still allow for Bedika of a Kerut Shofkha to allow him to marry an Aylonit?
– Double AA♦
Nov 28 at 1:53
I'm not familiar with that. I thought we don't ever allow bedikos for marriage. If you have something to share I'd be iinterested in seeing it.
– user6591
Nov 28 at 2:11
I'm not familiar with that. I thought we don't ever allow bedikos for marriage. If you have something to share I'd be iinterested in seeing it.
– user6591
Nov 28 at 2:11
I thought RMFs whole proof was from a Gemara in Yevamot about checking a Krut Shofkha to see if he could marry, and IVF is a Kol Shekein
– Double AA♦
Nov 28 at 2:16
I thought RMFs whole proof was from a Gemara in Yevamot about checking a Krut Shofkha to see if he could marry, and IVF is a Kol Shekein
– Double AA♦
Nov 28 at 2:16
@Double He mentions the theoretical case of using hot bread to test without niuf yes, but I don't think he believes that is actually muttar to do. The gemara itself was docheh that approach. Have you ever seen someone allowing that bedika?
– user6591
Nov 28 at 2:49
@Double He mentions the theoretical case of using hot bread to test without niuf yes, but I don't think he believes that is actually muttar to do. The gemara itself was docheh that approach. Have you ever seen someone allowing that bedika?
– user6591
Nov 28 at 2:49
2
2
This answer would be vastly improved if it would at the very least list the responsa of R'MF it refers to. Ideally, it should say how it got from them to its conclusions. Oh, and translating words into English would help, too.
– msh210♦
Nov 28 at 4:25
This answer would be vastly improved if it would at the very least list the responsa of R'MF it refers to. Ideally, it should say how it got from them to its conclusions. Oh, and translating words into English would help, too.
– msh210♦
Nov 28 at 4:25
|
show 2 more comments
