Proving $ A_i $ and $ A_j $ are independent events
up vote
0
down vote
favorite
I toss a fair coin $ 10 $ times. $ A_i (i = 1,2,dots,9) $ is the event of the same result in the $ i $ and $ i + 1 $ toss. How do I prove that for every $ i not = j $ the events $ A_i, A_j $ are independent?
I understand that in order to prove the independent of those two events I need to prove that $$ P(A_i | A_j) = P(A_i) P(A_j) $$
I guess I can conut on the fact that $ i, i+1 $ are indepedent events because it is a fair coin. so $ P(A_i) = P(A_j) = frac{1}{2} $ because I can have whatever result I want in the first toss and then I need the same results in the second. so
$$ P(A_j|A_i) = frac{P(A_jcap A_i)}{P(A_i)} = frac{frac{1}{2}^3}{frac{1}{2}} = frac{1}{4} = P(A_i)P(A_j) $$
But what if for example $ i =1 , j = 2 $ it means I should have the same result only in the first, second and third toss and then $ P(A_j | A_i) not = P(A_i)P(A_j) $
am I correct?
probability conditional-probability
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
favorite
I toss a fair coin $ 10 $ times. $ A_i (i = 1,2,dots,9) $ is the event of the same result in the $ i $ and $ i + 1 $ toss. How do I prove that for every $ i not = j $ the events $ A_i, A_j $ are independent?
I understand that in order to prove the independent of those two events I need to prove that $$ P(A_i | A_j) = P(A_i) P(A_j) $$
I guess I can conut on the fact that $ i, i+1 $ are indepedent events because it is a fair coin. so $ P(A_i) = P(A_j) = frac{1}{2} $ because I can have whatever result I want in the first toss and then I need the same results in the second. so
$$ P(A_j|A_i) = frac{P(A_jcap A_i)}{P(A_i)} = frac{frac{1}{2}^3}{frac{1}{2}} = frac{1}{4} = P(A_i)P(A_j) $$
But what if for example $ i =1 , j = 2 $ it means I should have the same result only in the first, second and third toss and then $ P(A_j | A_i) not = P(A_i)P(A_j) $
am I correct?
probability conditional-probability
you nts that $mathsf{P}(A_icap A_j)=mathsf{P}(A_i)mathsf{P}(A_j)$ or $mathsf{P}(A_imid A_j)=mathsf{P}(A_i)$...
– d.k.o.
Nov 19 at 9:39
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
favorite
up vote
0
down vote
favorite
I toss a fair coin $ 10 $ times. $ A_i (i = 1,2,dots,9) $ is the event of the same result in the $ i $ and $ i + 1 $ toss. How do I prove that for every $ i not = j $ the events $ A_i, A_j $ are independent?
I understand that in order to prove the independent of those two events I need to prove that $$ P(A_i | A_j) = P(A_i) P(A_j) $$
I guess I can conut on the fact that $ i, i+1 $ are indepedent events because it is a fair coin. so $ P(A_i) = P(A_j) = frac{1}{2} $ because I can have whatever result I want in the first toss and then I need the same results in the second. so
$$ P(A_j|A_i) = frac{P(A_jcap A_i)}{P(A_i)} = frac{frac{1}{2}^3}{frac{1}{2}} = frac{1}{4} = P(A_i)P(A_j) $$
But what if for example $ i =1 , j = 2 $ it means I should have the same result only in the first, second and third toss and then $ P(A_j | A_i) not = P(A_i)P(A_j) $
am I correct?
probability conditional-probability
I toss a fair coin $ 10 $ times. $ A_i (i = 1,2,dots,9) $ is the event of the same result in the $ i $ and $ i + 1 $ toss. How do I prove that for every $ i not = j $ the events $ A_i, A_j $ are independent?
I understand that in order to prove the independent of those two events I need to prove that $$ P(A_i | A_j) = P(A_i) P(A_j) $$
I guess I can conut on the fact that $ i, i+1 $ are indepedent events because it is a fair coin. so $ P(A_i) = P(A_j) = frac{1}{2} $ because I can have whatever result I want in the first toss and then I need the same results in the second. so
$$ P(A_j|A_i) = frac{P(A_jcap A_i)}{P(A_i)} = frac{frac{1}{2}^3}{frac{1}{2}} = frac{1}{4} = P(A_i)P(A_j) $$
But what if for example $ i =1 , j = 2 $ it means I should have the same result only in the first, second and third toss and then $ P(A_j | A_i) not = P(A_i)P(A_j) $
am I correct?
probability conditional-probability
probability conditional-probability
asked Nov 19 at 9:35
bm1125
56116
56116
you nts that $mathsf{P}(A_icap A_j)=mathsf{P}(A_i)mathsf{P}(A_j)$ or $mathsf{P}(A_imid A_j)=mathsf{P}(A_i)$...
– d.k.o.
Nov 19 at 9:39
add a comment |
you nts that $mathsf{P}(A_icap A_j)=mathsf{P}(A_i)mathsf{P}(A_j)$ or $mathsf{P}(A_imid A_j)=mathsf{P}(A_i)$...
– d.k.o.
Nov 19 at 9:39
you nts that $mathsf{P}(A_icap A_j)=mathsf{P}(A_i)mathsf{P}(A_j)$ or $mathsf{P}(A_imid A_j)=mathsf{P}(A_i)$...
– d.k.o.
Nov 19 at 9:39
you nts that $mathsf{P}(A_icap A_j)=mathsf{P}(A_i)mathsf{P}(A_j)$ or $mathsf{P}(A_imid A_j)=mathsf{P}(A_i)$...
– d.k.o.
Nov 19 at 9:39
add a comment |
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
up vote
1
down vote
accepted
$P(A_1cap A_2)=frac 1 8 +frac 1 8=frac 1 4$ and $P(A_1)=P(A_2)=frac 1 2$ so $A_1$ and $A_2$ are independent.
Hey thanks for your answer. Can you explain just why $ P(A_1 cap A_2) = frac{1}{8} + frac{1}{8} $ I'm not sure what am I missing..
– bm1125
Nov 19 at 9:47
1
Probability of all three heads is $frac 1 8$ and probability of all three tails is also $frac 1 8$. You have to add these to get probability of $A_1cap A_2$.
– Kavi Rama Murthy
Nov 19 at 9:51
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
Two events are independent if
begin{equation}
P(Acap B) = P(A)P(B).
end{equation}
Alterativelly if
begin{equation}
P(A| B) = P(A).
end{equation}
Also $P(A_j cap A_i) =frac{1}{4} iff i+1=j.
Thanks for the answer, Let me make sure I understand $ P(A_j cap A_i) $ is the probability of having the same result in four tosses? Shouldn't it be $ frac{1}{2}^3 $ then? Because I can have whatever result on the first throw and then the next three throws should have the same result. What am I missing?
– bm1125
Nov 19 at 9:46
1
I thought that $i+1 = j$, my mistake :) In general it's $frac{1}{8}$, but when $j=i+1$ then it's $frac{1}{4}$
– vermator
Nov 19 at 9:58
No, you are right. I specifically asked about the case of $ i+1 = j $ . Thanks for clarifying!
– bm1125
Nov 19 at 10:00
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
You are asked to prove that for $A_1,dots,A_{10}$ are pairwise independent.
In this answer I go for a stronger result: $A_1,dots,A_{10}$ are mutually independent.
See here for the difference.
Work in probability space $(Omega,wp(Omega),P)$ where: $$Omega={H,T}^{10}={(omega_1,dots,omega_{10})mid omega_iin{H,T}text{ for every }iin{1,dots,10}}$$and $P({omega})=2^{-10}$ for every $omegainOmega$.
Let $E_iin{A_i,A_i^{complement}}$ for $i=1,dots,9$.
Every $omega=(omega_1,dots,omega_{10})in E_1capcdotscap E_9$ is completely determined by $omega_1$ so that $E_1capcdotscap E_9$ contains exactly $2$ elements of $Omega$.
So $P(E_1capcdotscap E_9)=2cdot2^{-10}=2^{-9}=P(E_1)timescdotstimes P(E_{9})$
This allows the conclusion that $A_1,dots,A_9$ are mutually independent.
Consequently $A_1,dots,A_9$ are also pairwise independent.
add a comment |
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
1
down vote
accepted
$P(A_1cap A_2)=frac 1 8 +frac 1 8=frac 1 4$ and $P(A_1)=P(A_2)=frac 1 2$ so $A_1$ and $A_2$ are independent.
Hey thanks for your answer. Can you explain just why $ P(A_1 cap A_2) = frac{1}{8} + frac{1}{8} $ I'm not sure what am I missing..
– bm1125
Nov 19 at 9:47
1
Probability of all three heads is $frac 1 8$ and probability of all three tails is also $frac 1 8$. You have to add these to get probability of $A_1cap A_2$.
– Kavi Rama Murthy
Nov 19 at 9:51
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
accepted
$P(A_1cap A_2)=frac 1 8 +frac 1 8=frac 1 4$ and $P(A_1)=P(A_2)=frac 1 2$ so $A_1$ and $A_2$ are independent.
Hey thanks for your answer. Can you explain just why $ P(A_1 cap A_2) = frac{1}{8} + frac{1}{8} $ I'm not sure what am I missing..
– bm1125
Nov 19 at 9:47
1
Probability of all three heads is $frac 1 8$ and probability of all three tails is also $frac 1 8$. You have to add these to get probability of $A_1cap A_2$.
– Kavi Rama Murthy
Nov 19 at 9:51
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
accepted
up vote
1
down vote
accepted
$P(A_1cap A_2)=frac 1 8 +frac 1 8=frac 1 4$ and $P(A_1)=P(A_2)=frac 1 2$ so $A_1$ and $A_2$ are independent.
$P(A_1cap A_2)=frac 1 8 +frac 1 8=frac 1 4$ and $P(A_1)=P(A_2)=frac 1 2$ so $A_1$ and $A_2$ are independent.
answered Nov 19 at 9:39
Kavi Rama Murthy
46k31854
46k31854
Hey thanks for your answer. Can you explain just why $ P(A_1 cap A_2) = frac{1}{8} + frac{1}{8} $ I'm not sure what am I missing..
– bm1125
Nov 19 at 9:47
1
Probability of all three heads is $frac 1 8$ and probability of all three tails is also $frac 1 8$. You have to add these to get probability of $A_1cap A_2$.
– Kavi Rama Murthy
Nov 19 at 9:51
add a comment |
Hey thanks for your answer. Can you explain just why $ P(A_1 cap A_2) = frac{1}{8} + frac{1}{8} $ I'm not sure what am I missing..
– bm1125
Nov 19 at 9:47
1
Probability of all three heads is $frac 1 8$ and probability of all three tails is also $frac 1 8$. You have to add these to get probability of $A_1cap A_2$.
– Kavi Rama Murthy
Nov 19 at 9:51
Hey thanks for your answer. Can you explain just why $ P(A_1 cap A_2) = frac{1}{8} + frac{1}{8} $ I'm not sure what am I missing..
– bm1125
Nov 19 at 9:47
Hey thanks for your answer. Can you explain just why $ P(A_1 cap A_2) = frac{1}{8} + frac{1}{8} $ I'm not sure what am I missing..
– bm1125
Nov 19 at 9:47
1
1
Probability of all three heads is $frac 1 8$ and probability of all three tails is also $frac 1 8$. You have to add these to get probability of $A_1cap A_2$.
– Kavi Rama Murthy
Nov 19 at 9:51
Probability of all three heads is $frac 1 8$ and probability of all three tails is also $frac 1 8$. You have to add these to get probability of $A_1cap A_2$.
– Kavi Rama Murthy
Nov 19 at 9:51
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
Two events are independent if
begin{equation}
P(Acap B) = P(A)P(B).
end{equation}
Alterativelly if
begin{equation}
P(A| B) = P(A).
end{equation}
Also $P(A_j cap A_i) =frac{1}{4} iff i+1=j.
Thanks for the answer, Let me make sure I understand $ P(A_j cap A_i) $ is the probability of having the same result in four tosses? Shouldn't it be $ frac{1}{2}^3 $ then? Because I can have whatever result on the first throw and then the next three throws should have the same result. What am I missing?
– bm1125
Nov 19 at 9:46
1
I thought that $i+1 = j$, my mistake :) In general it's $frac{1}{8}$, but when $j=i+1$ then it's $frac{1}{4}$
– vermator
Nov 19 at 9:58
No, you are right. I specifically asked about the case of $ i+1 = j $ . Thanks for clarifying!
– bm1125
Nov 19 at 10:00
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
Two events are independent if
begin{equation}
P(Acap B) = P(A)P(B).
end{equation}
Alterativelly if
begin{equation}
P(A| B) = P(A).
end{equation}
Also $P(A_j cap A_i) =frac{1}{4} iff i+1=j.
Thanks for the answer, Let me make sure I understand $ P(A_j cap A_i) $ is the probability of having the same result in four tosses? Shouldn't it be $ frac{1}{2}^3 $ then? Because I can have whatever result on the first throw and then the next three throws should have the same result. What am I missing?
– bm1125
Nov 19 at 9:46
1
I thought that $i+1 = j$, my mistake :) In general it's $frac{1}{8}$, but when $j=i+1$ then it's $frac{1}{4}$
– vermator
Nov 19 at 9:58
No, you are right. I specifically asked about the case of $ i+1 = j $ . Thanks for clarifying!
– bm1125
Nov 19 at 10:00
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
up vote
1
down vote
Two events are independent if
begin{equation}
P(Acap B) = P(A)P(B).
end{equation}
Alterativelly if
begin{equation}
P(A| B) = P(A).
end{equation}
Also $P(A_j cap A_i) =frac{1}{4} iff i+1=j.
Two events are independent if
begin{equation}
P(Acap B) = P(A)P(B).
end{equation}
Alterativelly if
begin{equation}
P(A| B) = P(A).
end{equation}
Also $P(A_j cap A_i) =frac{1}{4} iff i+1=j.
edited Nov 19 at 10:03
answered Nov 19 at 9:44
vermator
795
795
Thanks for the answer, Let me make sure I understand $ P(A_j cap A_i) $ is the probability of having the same result in four tosses? Shouldn't it be $ frac{1}{2}^3 $ then? Because I can have whatever result on the first throw and then the next three throws should have the same result. What am I missing?
– bm1125
Nov 19 at 9:46
1
I thought that $i+1 = j$, my mistake :) In general it's $frac{1}{8}$, but when $j=i+1$ then it's $frac{1}{4}$
– vermator
Nov 19 at 9:58
No, you are right. I specifically asked about the case of $ i+1 = j $ . Thanks for clarifying!
– bm1125
Nov 19 at 10:00
add a comment |
Thanks for the answer, Let me make sure I understand $ P(A_j cap A_i) $ is the probability of having the same result in four tosses? Shouldn't it be $ frac{1}{2}^3 $ then? Because I can have whatever result on the first throw and then the next three throws should have the same result. What am I missing?
– bm1125
Nov 19 at 9:46
1
I thought that $i+1 = j$, my mistake :) In general it's $frac{1}{8}$, but when $j=i+1$ then it's $frac{1}{4}$
– vermator
Nov 19 at 9:58
No, you are right. I specifically asked about the case of $ i+1 = j $ . Thanks for clarifying!
– bm1125
Nov 19 at 10:00
Thanks for the answer, Let me make sure I understand $ P(A_j cap A_i) $ is the probability of having the same result in four tosses? Shouldn't it be $ frac{1}{2}^3 $ then? Because I can have whatever result on the first throw and then the next three throws should have the same result. What am I missing?
– bm1125
Nov 19 at 9:46
Thanks for the answer, Let me make sure I understand $ P(A_j cap A_i) $ is the probability of having the same result in four tosses? Shouldn't it be $ frac{1}{2}^3 $ then? Because I can have whatever result on the first throw and then the next three throws should have the same result. What am I missing?
– bm1125
Nov 19 at 9:46
1
1
I thought that $i+1 = j$, my mistake :) In general it's $frac{1}{8}$, but when $j=i+1$ then it's $frac{1}{4}$
– vermator
Nov 19 at 9:58
I thought that $i+1 = j$, my mistake :) In general it's $frac{1}{8}$, but when $j=i+1$ then it's $frac{1}{4}$
– vermator
Nov 19 at 9:58
No, you are right. I specifically asked about the case of $ i+1 = j $ . Thanks for clarifying!
– bm1125
Nov 19 at 10:00
No, you are right. I specifically asked about the case of $ i+1 = j $ . Thanks for clarifying!
– bm1125
Nov 19 at 10:00
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
You are asked to prove that for $A_1,dots,A_{10}$ are pairwise independent.
In this answer I go for a stronger result: $A_1,dots,A_{10}$ are mutually independent.
See here for the difference.
Work in probability space $(Omega,wp(Omega),P)$ where: $$Omega={H,T}^{10}={(omega_1,dots,omega_{10})mid omega_iin{H,T}text{ for every }iin{1,dots,10}}$$and $P({omega})=2^{-10}$ for every $omegainOmega$.
Let $E_iin{A_i,A_i^{complement}}$ for $i=1,dots,9$.
Every $omega=(omega_1,dots,omega_{10})in E_1capcdotscap E_9$ is completely determined by $omega_1$ so that $E_1capcdotscap E_9$ contains exactly $2$ elements of $Omega$.
So $P(E_1capcdotscap E_9)=2cdot2^{-10}=2^{-9}=P(E_1)timescdotstimes P(E_{9})$
This allows the conclusion that $A_1,dots,A_9$ are mutually independent.
Consequently $A_1,dots,A_9$ are also pairwise independent.
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
You are asked to prove that for $A_1,dots,A_{10}$ are pairwise independent.
In this answer I go for a stronger result: $A_1,dots,A_{10}$ are mutually independent.
See here for the difference.
Work in probability space $(Omega,wp(Omega),P)$ where: $$Omega={H,T}^{10}={(omega_1,dots,omega_{10})mid omega_iin{H,T}text{ for every }iin{1,dots,10}}$$and $P({omega})=2^{-10}$ for every $omegainOmega$.
Let $E_iin{A_i,A_i^{complement}}$ for $i=1,dots,9$.
Every $omega=(omega_1,dots,omega_{10})in E_1capcdotscap E_9$ is completely determined by $omega_1$ so that $E_1capcdotscap E_9$ contains exactly $2$ elements of $Omega$.
So $P(E_1capcdotscap E_9)=2cdot2^{-10}=2^{-9}=P(E_1)timescdotstimes P(E_{9})$
This allows the conclusion that $A_1,dots,A_9$ are mutually independent.
Consequently $A_1,dots,A_9$ are also pairwise independent.
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
up vote
1
down vote
You are asked to prove that for $A_1,dots,A_{10}$ are pairwise independent.
In this answer I go for a stronger result: $A_1,dots,A_{10}$ are mutually independent.
See here for the difference.
Work in probability space $(Omega,wp(Omega),P)$ where: $$Omega={H,T}^{10}={(omega_1,dots,omega_{10})mid omega_iin{H,T}text{ for every }iin{1,dots,10}}$$and $P({omega})=2^{-10}$ for every $omegainOmega$.
Let $E_iin{A_i,A_i^{complement}}$ for $i=1,dots,9$.
Every $omega=(omega_1,dots,omega_{10})in E_1capcdotscap E_9$ is completely determined by $omega_1$ so that $E_1capcdotscap E_9$ contains exactly $2$ elements of $Omega$.
So $P(E_1capcdotscap E_9)=2cdot2^{-10}=2^{-9}=P(E_1)timescdotstimes P(E_{9})$
This allows the conclusion that $A_1,dots,A_9$ are mutually independent.
Consequently $A_1,dots,A_9$ are also pairwise independent.
You are asked to prove that for $A_1,dots,A_{10}$ are pairwise independent.
In this answer I go for a stronger result: $A_1,dots,A_{10}$ are mutually independent.
See here for the difference.
Work in probability space $(Omega,wp(Omega),P)$ where: $$Omega={H,T}^{10}={(omega_1,dots,omega_{10})mid omega_iin{H,T}text{ for every }iin{1,dots,10}}$$and $P({omega})=2^{-10}$ for every $omegainOmega$.
Let $E_iin{A_i,A_i^{complement}}$ for $i=1,dots,9$.
Every $omega=(omega_1,dots,omega_{10})in E_1capcdotscap E_9$ is completely determined by $omega_1$ so that $E_1capcdotscap E_9$ contains exactly $2$ elements of $Omega$.
So $P(E_1capcdotscap E_9)=2cdot2^{-10}=2^{-9}=P(E_1)timescdotstimes P(E_{9})$
This allows the conclusion that $A_1,dots,A_9$ are mutually independent.
Consequently $A_1,dots,A_9$ are also pairwise independent.
edited Nov 19 at 10:13
answered Nov 19 at 10:01
drhab
95.7k543126
95.7k543126
add a comment |
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to Mathematics Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Some of your past answers have not been well-received, and you're in danger of being blocked from answering.
Please pay close attention to the following guidance:
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f3004699%2fproving-a-i-and-a-j-are-independent-events%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
you nts that $mathsf{P}(A_icap A_j)=mathsf{P}(A_i)mathsf{P}(A_j)$ or $mathsf{P}(A_imid A_j)=mathsf{P}(A_i)$...
– d.k.o.
Nov 19 at 9:39