Is it possible to have a Jewish wedding after a civil ceremony?
My (legal) husband and I had a small courthouse wedding ceremony, which was done entirely for practical reasons after my cancer diagnosis. Neither of us are as frum now as we were raised, but having a Jewish wedding ceremony and ketubah is very important to us. Is there any halachic reason why we couldn't now have a Jewish wedding ceremony?
halacha wedding civil-procedure
edited Jan 19 at 18:33
mbloch
23.5k443114
asked Jan 19 at 18:18
AthenaFluteAthenaFlute
512
add a comment |
My (legal) husband and I had a small courthouse wedding ceremony, which was done entirely for practical reasons after my cancer diagnosis. Neither of us are as frum now as we were raised, but having a Jewish wedding ceremony and ketubah is very important to us. Is there any halachic reason why we couldn't now have a Jewish wedding ceremony?
halacha wedding civil-procedure
edited Jan 19 at 18:33
mbloch
23.5k443114
asked Jan 19 at 18:18
AthenaFluteAthenaFlute
512
1
Welcome to MiYodeya AthenaFlute. Great to have you learn with us!
– mbloch
Jan 19 at 18:26
6
Best wishes for your recovery!
– Heshy
Jan 20 at 15:12
I know lots of people who've done it.
– Shalom
Jan 20 at 20:18
add a comment |
My (legal) husband and I had a small courthouse wedding ceremony, which was done entirely for practical reasons after my cancer diagnosis. Neither of us are as frum now as we were raised, but having a Jewish wedding ceremony and ketubah is very important to us. Is there any halachic reason why we couldn't now have a Jewish wedding ceremony?
halacha wedding civil-procedure
edited Jan 19 at 18:33
mbloch
23.5k443114
asked Jan 19 at 18:18
AthenaFluteAthenaFlute
512
My (legal) husband and I had a small courthouse wedding ceremony, which was done entirely for practical reasons after my cancer diagnosis. Neither of us are as frum now as we were raised, but having a Jewish wedding ceremony and ketubah is very important to us. Is there any halachic reason why we couldn't now have a Jewish wedding ceremony?
halacha wedding civil-procedure
halacha wedding civil-procedure
edited Jan 19 at 18:33
mbloch
23.5k443114
asked Jan 19 at 18:18
AthenaFluteAthenaFlute
512
edited Jan 19 at 18:33
mbloch
23.5k443114
asked Jan 19 at 18:18
AthenaFluteAthenaFlute
512
edited Jan 19 at 18:33
mbloch
23.5k443114
edited Jan 19 at 18:33
mbloch
23.5k443114
edited Jan 19 at 18:33
mbloch
23.5k443114
23.5k443114
asked Jan 19 at 18:18
AthenaFluteAthenaFlute
512
asked Jan 19 at 18:18
AthenaFluteAthenaFlute
512
asked Jan 19 at 18:18
AthenaFluteAthenaFlute
512
512
1
Welcome to MiYodeya AthenaFlute. Great to have you learn with us!
– mbloch
Jan 19 at 18:26
6
Best wishes for your recovery!
– Heshy
Jan 20 at 15:12
I know lots of people who've done it.
– Shalom
Jan 20 at 20:18
add a comment |
1
Welcome to MiYodeya AthenaFlute. Great to have you learn with us!
– mbloch
Jan 19 at 18:26
6
Best wishes for your recovery!
– Heshy
Jan 20 at 15:12
I know lots of people who've done it.
– Shalom
Jan 20 at 20:18
1
1
Welcome to MiYodeya AthenaFlute. Great to have you learn with us!
– mbloch
Jan 19 at 18:26
Welcome to MiYodeya AthenaFlute. Great to have you learn with us!
– mbloch
Jan 19 at 18:26
6
6
Best wishes for your recovery!
– Heshy
Jan 20 at 15:12
Best wishes for your recovery!
– Heshy
Jan 20 at 15:12
I know lots of people who've done it.
– Shalom
Jan 20 at 20:18
I know lots of people who've done it.
– Shalom
Jan 20 at 20:18
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
There is no reason not to have a Jewish wedding. On the contrary! There is a strong reason to have one, in order to live according to halacha with a kosher wedding and ketuba.
Note that, in many European countries (e.g., Switzerland, France), it is forbidden to have a Jewish wedding without first having a civil wedding. As such, all Jews first have a small wedding ceremony in front of civil authorities, and soon after that the real Jewish wedding.
With best wishes for a beautiful kosher wedding. Mazal tov!
edited Jan 20 at 4:48
Alex
19.6k149105
answered Jan 19 at 18:32
mblochmbloch
23.5k443114
1
In the general case as I originally thought from the title, could there an issue with making brachos, as per judaism.stackexchange.com/a/14148 that the civil ceremony might have been halachically valid? In the OP's case it seems that nobody had any daas that it should be halachically valid so you're definitely right.
– Heshy
Jan 20 at 15:16
add a comment |
Actually, there is a reason not to have a Jewish wedding, although I hope it does not apply to you. If there is concern that there may eventually be a civil divorce, without a proper Get (Jewish divorce), then it is better that the original should not be binding according to Jewish Law. See Igros Moshe Even HaEzer I, Siman 74, where he argues on Rav Eliyahu Henkin, and in Even HaEzer II, Siman 19 he says the children from a subsequent marriage would be kosher.
(The question of whether a civil marriage needs a Jewish divorce is beyond the scope of this question)
answered Jan 20 at 19:31
arecapsarecaps
945
I assume I got down voted because I did not quote a source, so I added one.
– arecaps
Jan 21 at 4:08
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
There is no reason not to have a Jewish wedding. On the contrary! There is a strong reason to have one, in order to live according to halacha with a kosher wedding and ketuba.
Note that, in many European countries (e.g., Switzerland, France), it is forbidden to have a Jewish wedding without first having a civil wedding. As such, all Jews first have a small wedding ceremony in front of civil authorities, and soon after that the real Jewish wedding.
With best wishes for a beautiful kosher wedding. Mazal tov!
edited Jan 20 at 4:48
Alex
19.6k149105
answered Jan 19 at 18:32
mblochmbloch
23.5k443114
1
In the general case as I originally thought from the title, could there an issue with making brachos, as per judaism.stackexchange.com/a/14148 that the civil ceremony might have been halachically valid? In the OP's case it seems that nobody had any daas that it should be halachically valid so you're definitely right.
– Heshy
Jan 20 at 15:16
add a comment |
There is no reason not to have a Jewish wedding. On the contrary! There is a strong reason to have one, in order to live according to halacha with a kosher wedding and ketuba.
Note that, in many European countries (e.g., Switzerland, France), it is forbidden to have a Jewish wedding without first having a civil wedding. As such, all Jews first have a small wedding ceremony in front of civil authorities, and soon after that the real Jewish wedding.
With best wishes for a beautiful kosher wedding. Mazal tov!
edited Jan 20 at 4:48
Alex
19.6k149105
answered Jan 19 at 18:32
mblochmbloch
23.5k443114
1
In the general case as I originally thought from the title, could there an issue with making brachos, as per judaism.stackexchange.com/a/14148 that the civil ceremony might have been halachically valid? In the OP's case it seems that nobody had any daas that it should be halachically valid so you're definitely right.
– Heshy
Jan 20 at 15:16
add a comment |
There is no reason not to have a Jewish wedding. On the contrary! There is a strong reason to have one, in order to live according to halacha with a kosher wedding and ketuba.
Note that, in many European countries (e.g., Switzerland, France), it is forbidden to have a Jewish wedding without first having a civil wedding. As such, all Jews first have a small wedding ceremony in front of civil authorities, and soon after that the real Jewish wedding.
With best wishes for a beautiful kosher wedding. Mazal tov!
edited Jan 20 at 4:48
Alex
19.6k149105
answered Jan 19 at 18:32
mblochmbloch
23.5k443114
There is no reason not to have a Jewish wedding. On the contrary! There is a strong reason to have one, in order to live according to halacha with a kosher wedding and ketuba.
Note that, in many European countries (e.g., Switzerland, France), it is forbidden to have a Jewish wedding without first having a civil wedding. As such, all Jews first have a small wedding ceremony in front of civil authorities, and soon after that the real Jewish wedding.
With best wishes for a beautiful kosher wedding. Mazal tov!
edited Jan 20 at 4:48
Alex
19.6k149105
answered Jan 19 at 18:32
mblochmbloch
23.5k443114
edited Jan 20 at 4:48
Alex
19.6k149105
edited Jan 20 at 4:48
Alex
19.6k149105
edited Jan 20 at 4:48
Alex
19.6k149105
19.6k149105
answered Jan 19 at 18:32
mblochmbloch
23.5k443114
answered Jan 19 at 18:32
mblochmbloch
23.5k443114
answered Jan 19 at 18:32
mblochmbloch
23.5k443114
23.5k443114
1
In the general case as I originally thought from the title, could there an issue with making brachos, as per judaism.stackexchange.com/a/14148 that the civil ceremony might have been halachically valid? In the OP's case it seems that nobody had any daas that it should be halachically valid so you're definitely right.
– Heshy
Jan 20 at 15:16
add a comment |
1
In the general case as I originally thought from the title, could there an issue with making brachos, as per judaism.stackexchange.com/a/14148 that the civil ceremony might have been halachically valid? In the OP's case it seems that nobody had any daas that it should be halachically valid so you're definitely right.
– Heshy
Jan 20 at 15:16
1
1
In the general case as I originally thought from the title, could there an issue with making brachos, as per judaism.stackexchange.com/a/14148 that the civil ceremony might have been halachically valid? In the OP's case it seems that nobody had any daas that it should be halachically valid so you're definitely right.
– Heshy
Jan 20 at 15:16
In the general case as I originally thought from the title, could there an issue with making brachos, as per judaism.stackexchange.com/a/14148 that the civil ceremony might have been halachically valid? In the OP's case it seems that nobody had any daas that it should be halachically valid so you're definitely right.
– Heshy
Jan 20 at 15:16
add a comment |
Actually, there is a reason not to have a Jewish wedding, although I hope it does not apply to you. If there is concern that there may eventually be a civil divorce, without a proper Get (Jewish divorce), then it is better that the original should not be binding according to Jewish Law. See Igros Moshe Even HaEzer I, Siman 74, where he argues on Rav Eliyahu Henkin, and in Even HaEzer II, Siman 19 he says the children from a subsequent marriage would be kosher.
(The question of whether a civil marriage needs a Jewish divorce is beyond the scope of this question)
answered Jan 20 at 19:31
arecapsarecaps
945
I assume I got down voted because I did not quote a source, so I added one.
– arecaps
Jan 21 at 4:08
add a comment |
Actually, there is a reason not to have a Jewish wedding, although I hope it does not apply to you. If there is concern that there may eventually be a civil divorce, without a proper Get (Jewish divorce), then it is better that the original should not be binding according to Jewish Law. See Igros Moshe Even HaEzer I, Siman 74, where he argues on Rav Eliyahu Henkin, and in Even HaEzer II, Siman 19 he says the children from a subsequent marriage would be kosher.
(The question of whether a civil marriage needs a Jewish divorce is beyond the scope of this question)
answered Jan 20 at 19:31
arecapsarecaps
945
I assume I got down voted because I did not quote a source, so I added one.
– arecaps
Jan 21 at 4:08
add a comment |
Actually, there is a reason not to have a Jewish wedding, although I hope it does not apply to you. If there is concern that there may eventually be a civil divorce, without a proper Get (Jewish divorce), then it is better that the original should not be binding according to Jewish Law. See Igros Moshe Even HaEzer I, Siman 74, where he argues on Rav Eliyahu Henkin, and in Even HaEzer II, Siman 19 he says the children from a subsequent marriage would be kosher.
(The question of whether a civil marriage needs a Jewish divorce is beyond the scope of this question)
answered Jan 20 at 19:31
arecapsarecaps
945
Actually, there is a reason not to have a Jewish wedding, although I hope it does not apply to you. If there is concern that there may eventually be a civil divorce, without a proper Get (Jewish divorce), then it is better that the original should not be binding according to Jewish Law. See Igros Moshe Even HaEzer I, Siman 74, where he argues on Rav Eliyahu Henkin, and in Even HaEzer II, Siman 19 he says the children from a subsequent marriage would be kosher.
(The question of whether a civil marriage needs a Jewish divorce is beyond the scope of this question)
answered Jan 20 at 19:31
arecapsarecaps
945
edited Jan 21 at 4:07
answered Jan 20 at 19:31
arecapsarecaps
945
answered Jan 20 at 19:31
arecapsarecaps
945
answered Jan 20 at 19:31
arecapsarecaps
945
945
I assume I got down voted because I did not quote a source, so I added one.
– arecaps
Jan 21 at 4:08
add a comment |
I assume I got down voted because I did not quote a source, so I added one.
– arecaps
Jan 21 at 4:08
I assume I got down voted because I did not quote a source, so I added one.
– arecaps
Jan 21 at 4:08
I assume I got down voted because I did not quote a source, so I added one.
– arecaps
Jan 21 at 4:08
add a comment |
1
Welcome to MiYodeya AthenaFlute. Great to have you learn with us!
– mbloch
Jan 19 at 18:26
6
Best wishes for your recovery!
– Heshy
Jan 20 at 15:12
I know lots of people who've done it.
– Shalom
Jan 20 at 20:18